How two interacting waves simplify when dispersion is turned off: the dispersionless Manakov system and plane-wave stability
This paper studies what happens to a well-known two-component wave model when dispersive effects are negligible. The model is the Manakov system, an integrable two-component generalization of the nonlinear Schrödinger (NLS) equation. The authors derive the dispersionless, or semiclassical, limit of that system and use it to understand how counterpropagating plane waves change slowly in space and time and whether those waves are stable to small disturbances.
To get the dispersionless model the authors write each complex wave in polar form (a density and a phase) and introduce component velocities. They then drop the small “quantum pressure” terms that represent dispersion. This leads to a four-component first-order system of conservation laws for the two densities and two velocities. The system can be written compactly as y_t + M(y) y_x = 0, where M is a 4×4 coefficient matrix. The characteristic speeds of this hydrodynamic system are the four roots of a fourth-degree (quartic) polynomial whose coefficients depend on the densities and velocities.
Several structural results follow. The dispersionless system is shown to pass the Haantjes tensor test, a criterion used to indicate an integrable hydrodynamic structure. The paper proves that the branch points of the spectral curve associated with plane-wave solutions — the special points where different sheets of the algebraic curve meet — act as local Riemann invariants. In plain terms, those branch points provide natural coordinates that diagonalize the modulation equations locally. The proof uses an exact algebraic identity showing that the gradient of a simple branch point is a left eigenvector of the hydrodynamic matrix.
The authors then use this dispersionless picture to study modulational stability. By examining the characteristic speeds they classify the “baseband” modulational stability and instability of counterpropagating plane waves. They also linearize the original Manakov system to study finite-wavenumber (shorter wavelength) perturbations and show that the Whitham, or long-wave, prediction from the dispersionless theory is recovered in the long-wavelength limit. A degenerate case that appears in the Whitham analysis is resolved: the boundary that looks neutral becomes unstable once arbitrarily small nonzero perturbation wavenumbers are allowed. The paper derives discriminant criteria for the linearized spectrum and presents results on how the growth rate of instabilities depends on parameters.