How tiny differences in kaon and pion decays could point to new physics
This paper studies how much we can learn by measuring very precisely how charged kaons and pions decay into a charged lepton (an electron or a muon) and a neutrino. These “purely leptonic” decays are simple in the Standard Model of particle physics. That simplicity makes them a good place to look for small deviations that might come from new particles or forces.
The authors focus on a few ratios of decay rates that cancel many common errors. One set is the single ratios R_{Kπ}^ℓ = Γ(K→ℓν)/Γ(π→ℓν) for ℓ = e (electron) or μ (muon). Another is the double ratio R_{Kπ}^e / R_{Kπ}^μ, which cancels even more experimental uncertainty and is especially clean theoretically. The paper quotes current numbers from experiment and from recent lattice QCD theory calculations. For example, the electron mode for kaons is reported as about 2.488(9)×10^-5 experimentally and 2.47653(34)×10^-5 from theory, while the pion electron mode is about 1.2327(23)×10^-4 experimentally and 1.23501(10)×10^-4 from theory. A combined kaon-to-pion ratio for muons is given as 1.3367(28) experimentally and 1.316(6) in the Standard Model.
On the experimental side the paper sketches a dedicated new setup. The idea is to use a slowly extracted 400 GeV proton beam to make a focused, positive secondary hadron beam of about 25 GeV. The beamline would include magnetic focusing (quadrupoles), momentum selection with dipole magnets and a collimator, and systems to identify and track particles. The beam-preparation region is expected to be about 130 m long, possibly more, and the chosen momentum gives muons from pion decays a useful spread so they can be detected a few tens of centimetres away from the beam line. The authors estimate that a multi-year run with this concept could reach a final precision at the 10^-4 level.
Why does this matter? The Standard Model rates are now known, in some cases, to a precision similar to what the proposed experiment aims to reach, thanks to recent lattice QCD calculations. That means the data and theory could be compared tightly. Because the weak force in these decays is “left-handed” it causes a suppression of decays to light charged leptons (a feature called helicity suppression). New physics that acts like a scalar interaction would lift that suppression more for kaons than for pions, so comparing kaon and pion decays is a sensitive way to test for such effects. The double ratio in particular offers a very clean probe of violations of lepton flavour universality — the idea that electrons and muons interact the same way.